DS-2023-12: Views From a Peak: Generalisations and Descriptive Set Theory

DS-2023-12: Wontner, Ned J.H. (2023) Views From a Peak: Generalisations and Descriptive Set Theory. Doctoral thesis, Universiteit van Amsterdam.

[thumbnail of DS-2023-12.text.pdf] Text
DS-2023-12.text.pdf - Published Version

Download (8MB)
[thumbnail of Samenvatting] Text (Samenvatting)
DS-2023-12.samenvatting.txt - Other

Download (3kB)


This dissertation has two major threads, one is mathematical, namely descriptive set theory, the other is philosophical, namely generalisation in mathematics. Descriptive set theory is the study of the behaviour of definable subsets of a given structure such as the real numbers. In the core mathematical chapters, we provide mathematical results connecting descriptive set theory and generalised descriptive set theory. Using these, we give a philosophical account of the motivations for, and the nature of, generalisation in mathematics.
In Chapter 3, we stratify set theories based on this descriptive complexity. The axiom of countable choice for reals is one of the most basic fragments of the axiom of choice needed in many parts of mathematics. Descriptive choice principles are a further stratification of this fragment by the descriptive complexity of the sets. We provide a separation technique for descriptive choice principles based on Jensen forcing. Our results generalise a theorem by Kanovei.
Chapter 4 gives the essentials of a generalised real analysis, that is a real analysis on generalisations of the real numbers to higher infinities. This builds on work by Galeotti and his coauthors. We generalise classical theorems of real analysis to certain sets of functions, strengthening continuity, and disprove other classical theorems. We also show that a certain cardinal property, the tree property, is equivalent to the Extreme Value Theorem for a set of functions which generalise the continuous functions.
The question of Chapter 5 is whether a robust notion of infinite sums can be developed on generalisations of the real numbers to higher infinities. We state some incompatibility results, which suggest not. We analyse several candidate notions of infinite sum, both from the literature and more novel, and show which of the expected properties of a notion of sum they fail.
In Chapter 6, we study the descriptive set theory arising from a generalisation of topology, κ-topology, which is used in the previous two chapters. We show that the theory is quite different from that of the standard (full) topology. Differences include a collapsing Borel hierarchy, a lack of universal or complete sets, Lebesgue’s ‘great mistake’ holds (projections do not increase complexity), a strict hierarchy of notions of analyticity, and a failure of Suslin’s theorem.
Lastly, in Chapter 7, we give a philosophical account of the nature of generalisation in mathematics, and describe the methodological reasons that mathematicians generalise. In so doing, we distinguish generalisation from other processes of change in mathematics, such as abstraction and domain expansion. We suggest a semantic account of generalisation, where two pieces of mathematics constitute a generalisation if they have a certain relation of content, along with an increased level of generality.

Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Report Nr: DS-2023-12
Series Name: ILLC Dissertation (DS) Series
Year: 2023
Subjects: Logic
Divisions: Faculteit der Natuurwetenschappen, Wiskunde en Informatica
Depositing User: Dr Marco Vervoort
Date Deposited: 19 Feb 2024 13:32
Last Modified: 19 Feb 2024 13:32
URI: https://eprints.illc.uva.nl/id/eprint/2300

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item